So the other night we had a game of Donnybrook with Native Americans against Santa Anna's Mexicans.
A lone character charged a gun and managed to dispatch one of the crew, the three remaining crew managed a wound on the character which turned out to be just a scratch.
So one of the crew was removed from play and we then had to decide who if anyone had won the melee.
There were two schools of thought, firstly because the character had seen off one of the crew but had also been hit himself then it was a draw and the melee carried on when the relevant card was turned over.
The second thought was that because the gun crew unit had lost a figure but the character unit had not, the gun crew had lost and so had to take a morale check.
I was wondering which is correct? Or maybe neither are correct and there's a third way.
Having lots of fun with these rules by the way